The three legal forms for a not-for-profit in India look superficially similar — all of them allow you to pursue charitable objects, claim Section 12A / 12AB tax exemption, register for 80G donor benefits, and accept domestic funding. The differences emerge in the underlying governance framework, the registration cost and timeline, the scrutiny from regulators, the geographic spread of the organisation, and how foreign donors (FCRA-conscious) read the vehicle. Here is the working comparison.
Section 8 Company — Companies Act 2013
A Section 8 Company is incorporated under the Companies Act 2013 with the express object of promoting commerce, art, science, sports, education, research, social welfare, religion, charity, protection of environment, or any similar object. Profits are applied solely toward the object — no dividend can be paid.
Governance, registration and incident reporting follow the Companies Act framework. The vehicle has:
- Strongest governance signal. Board of directors, statutory audit by a Chartered Accountant, annual AOC-4 and MGT-7 filings, regulated under the MCA. Foreign donors (especially the larger ones) find Section 8 the easiest to diligence.
- Most expensive to incorporate and maintain. Incorporation costs are higher than a trust or society. Annual compliance includes statutory audit, board meetings, ROC filings — same as a private limited company except with the charitable wrapper.
- Pan-India operations are easy. The vehicle is a single MCA-incorporated entity, so operations across states don’t require state-specific registration.
- Conversion / dissolution requires Central Government approval — harder than dissolving a trust or society.
Public Charitable Trust — Indian Trusts Act 1882 (for private trusts) and state-specific Public Trusts Acts
A Public Charitable Trust is formed by execution of a trust deed on non-judicial stamp paper, registered with the local Sub-Registrar. There is no central registrar of charitable trusts — registration is state-specific. Maharashtra has the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act 1950 (which mandates registration with the Charity Commissioner); Gujarat has its own Public Trusts Act. Other states largely rely on the Indian Registration Act 1908 for trust-deed registration and the income-tax 12A / 12AB framework for tax recognition.
- Cheapest and quickest to set up. Trust deed drafting, stamp duty (state-specific), registration with the Sub-Registrar. Two trustees are the minimum. Most public charitable trusts have 3-5 trustees including the founder(s).
- Lighter ongoing compliance than a Section 8 Company. No board meetings under the Companies Act, no ROC filings. The income-tax compliance (audit under Section 12A, 10B / 10BB filing) is the principal annual burden.
- Trustee-driven governance. The trust deed specifies how trustees are appointed, how decisions are made, how trustees can be removed. There is no “members” layer — trustees collectively own the governance.
- Founder control. Trusts can be structured with the founder as a permanent trustee, with succession rules built into the deed. This is the reason most founder-led foundations (especially family-led charitable foundations) prefer the trust form.
- State-by-state setup required where the trust will hold immovable property in multiple states.
Society — Societies Registration Act 1860 (and state amendments)
A Society is registered under the Societies Registration Act 1860 (or its state-specific successors, such as the Karnataka Societies Registration Act 1960). A minimum of seven persons form the society, executing a Memorandum of Association and Rules and Regulations.
- Democratic governance. Society has “members” (the general body) and a “governing council” (the working board) elected periodically. Decisions are by majority of the general body or governing council. The structure is closer to a co-operative than to a company.
- Mid-tier compliance. Annual general meeting, governing-council meetings, annual filing of audited accounts with the state registrar. Lighter than a Section 8, heavier than a small trust.
- Registration is state-specific. A society registered in Karnataka can operate in other states but typically registers locally where it sets up offices. National-scale societies often register in Delhi (the central registrar) for pan-India recognition.
- Membership control matters. The general body has the power to amend the MOA, dissolve the society, change the office bearers. Founders who want longer-term control sometimes choose a trust instead.
The Income-tax common ground
Regardless of vehicle, the tax exemption under Section 12A / 12AB is available subject to registration with the Income-tax Department. The process is the same:
- Apply in Form 10A on the e-filing portal for provisional registration (valid 3 years)
- Within six months of the activities commencing, apply for final / regular registration in Form 10AB
- Renewed every 5 years (regular registration) under the framework introduced by the Finance Act 2020
- 80G registration for donor benefit (donors get 50% or 100% deduction depending on category) is a parallel application, also in Form 10A / 10AB
- Annual statement of donations in Form 10BD to enable donors to claim 80G — mandatory from FY 2021-22 onwards
All three vehicles can avail the same tax exemptions. The vehicle does not constrain the tax recognition.
FCRA — foreign donations
To accept foreign donations, an NGO needs registration under the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act 2010. FCRA registration is a separate, lengthy process administered by the Ministry of Home Affairs, with strict compliance requirements (designated SBI Main Branch FCRA bank account in New Delhi, quarterly returns, no sub-granting of FCRA funds, etc.).
FCRA recognises all three vehicles. In practice, large foreign donors prefer Section 8 Companies because:
- The board-of-directors governance is what their own boards understand
- The MCA filings provide a public audit trail that doesn’t exist as cleanly for trusts
- The Companies Act “significant beneficial owner” framework reduces beneficial-ownership ambiguity
For purely domestic funding, none of these matters.
CSR donations
To receive CSR funds from Indian corporates, the recipient NGO needs to be registered with the MCA under Form CSR-1 as a recognised implementing agency. The same Form CSR-1 is filed by all three vehicles; the eligibility is based on Section 12A / 12AB registration and a three-year track record of similar activities.
CSR funds can flow to any of the three vehicles. The donor company’s compliance burden is the same.
The picker
The choice usually settles on one of these patterns:
- Founder-led family foundation with a long-term endowment, modest annual operations, no foreign donor pipeline — Trust. Lowest cost, founder retains control via the trust deed, clean tax-exempt vehicle.
- Mid-sized civil-society organisation with multiple chapters, membership-based fundraising, advocacy work — Society. Democratic governance, member buy-in, state-level recognition.
- Funded NGO seeking foreign / institutional / CSR donors, plans for pan-India scale, professional executive team — Section 8 Company. Strongest governance signal, easiest diligence, harder to dilute.
Hybrid models exist — a Trust holding the endowment, with a separate Section 8 Company running operations; or a Society for fundraising paired with a Trust holding immovable property. These add complexity but can match a specific operational pattern.
Conversion paths
Conversion between the three forms is generally difficult. The cleanest path is to wind up the existing entity (distributing assets to a similar entity per the dissolution clause) and incorporate the new vehicle. This works only if the dissolution clause in the original deed / MOA permits transfer of assets to a similar entity. Many original deeds have such clauses precisely to allow future restructuring. We recommend including a similar-entity transfer clause in every NGO foundation deed for this reason.
Sources
Talk to a partner.
A 30-minute call with a partner — no deck, no follow-up email blasts. Just a read on how this applies to your facts.